Kentucky Sheriff Denies Murder Charges in Connection with District Court Judge’s Death

Letcher County Sheriff Pleads Not Guilty to Murder in Judge’s Death

In Letcher County, Kentucky, the community is still reeling from the shocking death of District Court Judge Kevin Mullins, who was tragically shot last week. On Wednesday, Sheriff Shawn “Mickey” Stines, 43, appeared in court remotely to enter a **not guilty** plea to a first-degree murder charge in connection with Mullins’ death. Stines remains behind bars without bond following this initial court appearance, which took place about 100 miles away from the courthouse where the incident occurred.

Details of the Incident

The shooting happened just days ago, on September 21. Although many details remain unclear, it has been reported that Sheriff Stines shot Judge Mullins in his chambers following a heated argument. Authorities indicated that while there were other individuals present in the courthouse at the time of the shooting, nobody was in the judge’s chambers. The state police are currently investigating what led to the tragic event.

Court Appearance and Reactions

During the arraignment, which was conducted via video from the Leslie County Detention Center, Stines did not make any statements regarding the charges. Judge Rupert Wilhoit took the opportunity to ask him about his financial situation after Stines expressed a desire for a court-appointed attorney. There was a notable skepticism from the judge when acknowledging Stines’ reported income of $115,000 as sheriff and two home properties, leaving questions about his claim of being indigent. A public defender, Josh Miller, chimed in, noting that Stines was in the process of losing his job and that his financial situation may soon change.

Community Impact

The tragic loss of Judge Mullins has left a tremendous void in Letcher County’s justice system, as he was known to many residents who valued his contributions. Circuit Court Clerk Mike Watts expressed deep sadness, referring to Mullins as not just a colleague, but a personal friend. Watts described the atmosphere in the county as “devastated” and said the killing of two well-respected figures has profoundly affected the community.

Background Context

Just days prior to the shooting, Sheriff Stines was deposed as part of a federal lawsuit. This case involved allegations against a former deputy under Stines’ command who was accused of coercing a woman. The lawsuit claims that Stines failed to adequately address the alleged misconduct, causing further complications in his role as a law enforcement leader.

Security Concerns Raised

In light of the shooting, many community members, including Commonwealth’s Attorney Matt Butler, are calling for improved security measures at the courthouse. Butler pointed out that the current setup at the Letcher County Courthouse lacks basic security measures, stating, “The Letcher County Courthouse is one of the last that you can walk into without a metal detector or security at the front door.” This sentiment reflects a broader concern about the safety and well-being of individuals who work in or visit the courthouse.

Next Steps in the Legal Process

A preliminary hearing to present evidence in Stines’ case is set for October 1 in Morgan County. With many unanswered questions about what transpired before Mullins was shot, the court proceedings will likely draw significant attention as the community seeks clarity and justice.

Final Thoughts

As the investigation continues, Letcher County grapples with the aftermath of this tragic event, and many are left wondering how such a heart-wrenching situation could occur between individuals who once shared mutual respect and friendship. Judge Mullins is survived by his wife and two daughters, and his legacy within the community is being remembered with fondness and respect.